Three ways to run the firm's software
- On a computer or a server in the office. The data is with you, but so are the backups, the updates and the safekeeping of the equipment.
- Shared SaaS (multi-tenant). The vendor runs one application, with one database, for all its customers. You open an account and start working.
- A dedicated installation in the cloud (single-tenant), also called private cloud. The vendor runs a copy of the application for your firm alone, with a separate server and database.
This article compares the last two, because that is the choice firms face today.
What "shared" means in practice
In a shared SaaS, your cases and those of other firms sit in the same tables. Each row carries an identifier of the firm, and the application shows each user only the rows of their own firm.
The model is widespread and can be done well. It has one property worth understanding: separation is a rule of the application. If the rule has an error, one firm's data can appear to another.
In a dedicated installation, the same error has nothing to show: the database holds only the firm's data.
Comparison
| Criterion | Shared SaaS | Dedicated installation |
|---|---|---|
| Database | Shared by all the vendor's customers | One for each firm |
| Documents | In the service's shared storage | In the firm's storage |
| Data separation | By the rules of the application | By separate resources |
| Address | On the vendor's domain | Can be on the firm's domain |
| Start | At once, with an account | After installation and configuration |
| Updates | For all customers at once | On each installation in turn |
| Cost | Usually lower | Usually higher |
What you gain and what you pay
A dedicated installation brings three things: isolation, control over where the data is kept, and a database that holds only the firm's data.
The price is the natural one: resources are no longer shared, so they cost more, and installation takes time. Someone also has to look after each installation: updates, backups, monitoring. Ask who does that.
Shared SaaS wins on simplicity. For many activities it is the right choice. The question is whether it is also right for a law firm's data.
Why it matters more for lawyers
In Romania, a lawyer must keep professional secrecy regarding any aspect of the case (Article 11 of Law no. 51/1995). The firm remains responsible for clients' data when it is held by a vendor, too (Articles 5(2) and 24 of the GDPR).
The GDPR asks for two things that bear directly on this choice:
- Article 28: the firm works only with vendors that provide sufficient guarantees, and signs a data processing agreement with them;
- Article 32: security measures are chosen according to the risk, taking the nature of the data into account.
Neither article imposes a model. Both ask you to be able to explain why you chose it.
What to ask the vendor
- Is the firm's database separate from other customers'?
- In which country, and with which data centre operator, is the data hosted?
- Who at the vendor can reach the server, and where is that access recorded?
- How often are backups made and where are they kept?
- What happens to the data when the contract ends?
- Which parts of the service are still shared between customers?
The last question is worth asking of a dedicated installation as well: it is rare for everything to be separate.
How AVODesk is built
AVODesk is installed separately for each firm:
- The server: the ERP and the AI assistants run on the firm's server.
- The database: your clients' data is not kept next to other firms' data.
- The documents: kept in the firm's private cloud, with antivirus and accounts for the whole team.
- The domain: the website, the portal and the cloud carry the firm's name.
The data is hosted in the European Union. ARCSoft installs the platform and updates it, and a backup of the data is made before every update.
One component is shared: the secure chat runs on the ARCSoft server, end-to-end encrypted. On request, the firm gets a dedicated chat server.
More on the Dedicated resources page.